Pastor Was 'Well-Loved by Many.' Then He Was Arrested and Accused of Drowning Cats

An Arkansas pastor is facing animal cruelty charges after police allege he drowned two cats, according to multiple news outlets, citing authorities.

Charles Thessing, 63, was arrested on Tuesday, Feb. 11, after police received a call from the West Memphis Animal Shelter about Thessing “allegedly committing acts of animal cruelty,” according to a statement from the West Memphis Police Department. 

Police said they searched Thessings’ home and allegedly found evidence of animal cruelty but did not provide further details about the allegations. 

Authorities confirmed to local outlets WREG and Fox 13 that Thessing is accused of drowning two cats.

Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for PEOPLE’s free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.  

Following his arrest, the Diocese of Little Rock’s bishop announced in a statement that Thessing had been suspended from his position as a pastor at St. Michael Church in West Memphis, pending the outcome of the criminal investigation. 

Bishop Anthony B. Taylor called the allegations “disturbing” but noted that Thessing “has many supporters — many whose lives he has positively impacted.”

“He is well-loved by many for bringing them and their families closer to God. During this difficult time, I would ask every person of good will — Father Thessing’s supporters and detractors alike — to keep him, your parishes and your school in your prayers.”

According to police, Thessing is charged with two counts of aggravated cruelty to animals. Jail records show Thessing has since been released on bond, WREG and Fox 13 report.

It’s unclear if he has entered a plea or retained an attorney to speak on his behalf.