PrivacyContact
Guns

Worn WWII-era M1 Carbine outshoots its mediocre-accuracy reputation

November 15, 2026

The M1 Carbine still gets dismissed as a close-range plinker with mediocre accuracy, but a recent hands-on review from GunsAmerica makes the case that a well-worn example can shoot a lot tighter than its reputation suggests.

Snapshot

GunsAmerica's review walks through the M1 Carbine's World War II background alongside live-fire testing with a battered Underwood-made example. The author reports the rifle grouped 2.5 to 3 inches at 100 yards, well ahead of the carbine's reputation for loose accuracy, while also praising its light weight and quick handling.

Key points

  • Accuracy on target: the Underwood carbine tested by GunsAmerica produced 2.5 to 3-inch groups at 100 yards despite its age and wear.
  • Reputation challenged: the author argues this performance pushes back on the carbine's long-standing reputation for mediocre accuracy.
  • Handling characteristics: the review highlights the platform's light weight and fast handling as a major part of its appeal.
  • Historical weight: the M1 Carbine's World War II service record is presented as adding to its overall appeal for shooters today.

Quick take

For a design pushing 80 years old, that kind of grouping at 100 yards is a solid showing, and it backs up what plenty of carbine owners have quietly known: condition and ammo matter more than the gun's old reputation. GunsAmerica's review is a good reminder that surplus-era rifles deserve a fair shake on the range before anyone writes them off.

Read the full story: gunsamerica.com