PrivacyContact
Guns

Benelli M2, M4 and M2-G1 Face Off in Live-Fire Shotgun Test

November 17, 2026

GunsAmerica put three Benelli shotgun actions head to head, running the inertia-driven M2, the new gas-operated M2-G1, and the military-proven M4 through several hundred rounds to see which action type actually holds up and runs fastest for duty and tactical use.

Snapshot

The comparison pits Benelli's three core shotgun platforms against each other on action type, cost, weight, and split times rather than spec-sheet claims. According to GunsAmerica, all three ran without malfunctions over the test, but the new M2-G1 posted the quickest split times of the group while undercutting the M4 EXT significantly on price.

Key points

  • Three distinct actions: the classic M2 runs Benelli's inertia-driven system, while the M2-G1 and M4 both use gas operation, with the M2-G1 specifically built around a rear-piston design.
  • M4 keeps the pedigree: GunsAmerica credits the M4 with the strongest track record of the three, citing its established combat and military service history.
  • M2-G1 is the speed and value play: the outlet reports it delivered the fastest testing performance of the group while costing substantially less than the M4 EXT.
  • Classic M2 stays lightest: the inertia gun remains the lightest option and runs clean, per the comparison, with no malfunctions logged across several hundred rounds fired.
  • One shared limit: none of the three shotguns reliably cycled very light target loads under 1,000 fps, according to the test.

Quick take

For buyers choosing between these three, GunsAmerica's testing suggests the decision comes down to priorities rather than a clear winner: track record favors the M4, speed and price favor the M2-G1, and weight and simplicity favor the classic M2. Ammunition compatibility matters across the board, since none handled the lightest loads well.

Read the full story: gunsamerica.com